Pontifex Maximus: A Short History of the Popes

Book Review

By Reviewed by Richard Brown, published 24th May 2018

Pontifex Maximus: A Short History of the Popes, Christopher Lascelles, Crux Publishing, 2017, 375pp., £9.99 paper, ISBN 978-1-909979-45-1

This book is aimed at the general reader who is short on time and seeks an accessible overview unencumbered by ecclesiastical jargon and scholarly controversies. Frank McLynn, author of Genghis Khan, Napoleon and 1066 writes that it is

'A brilliant book on a number of different levels. Lascelles has an engaging prose style and an amazing eye for detail and apposite anecdote. Surely only purblind Catholic zelanti will object to this outstanding analysis.'

For many people today, popes are an insignificance. If they consider them at all, it may be as harmless old men who preach obscure sermons in Latin. But the history of the popes is far from bland – rather occasionally so bizarre as to stretch credulity. Popes have led papal armies, fled in disguise, fathered children – including future popes – and authorised torture. They have been captured, assaulted and murdered. While many have been admired, some have been hated to such a degree that their funeral processions have been disrupted and statues of them torn down after their deaths. Many have been divisive rather than unifying figures, regarded as enemies of freedom and progress.

In a well-written and accessible volume, Christopher Lascelles examines the history of the popes through the ages, laying bare the extent to which many of them fell so very short of the Christian ideals they supposedly represented. He explains how it was that, professing to follow a man who said ‘My kingdom is not of this world’ and 'Lay not up for yourselves treasures upon earth’, they nevertheless became heads of a rich state that owned more land in Europe than any king, relying on foreign military aid to keep power; and how pride, greed and corruption became commonplace in an institution founded on love, faith and forgiveness.